COLLABORATION

The editorial team of the Indonesian Tourism Journal (ITJ) safeguards the integrity, independence, and fairness of the journal's scholarly publication process. Editorial decisions are based on academic quality and relevance to tourism research, not on financial, political, institutional, or personal considerations.
Editors evaluate manuscripts on scholarly merit, originality, research validity, clarity, relevance to the journal's tourism-focused scope, and ethical compliance. Editorial decisions must not be influenced by authors' identities, institutional affiliations, government policies, or outside interests.
Editors and editorial staff protect submitted material and related correspondence. Manuscript information is disclosed only to individuals legitimately involved in the editorial process, including corresponding authors, assigned or prospective reviewers, editorial advisers, and the publisher when appropriate.
Editors must disclose relevant professional, institutional, financial, or personal conflicts. An editor with such a conflict must not handle the affected manuscript and should delegate responsibility to an impartial colleague. Unpublished findings or ideas may not be used for personal benefit without the authors' written consent.
Manuscripts proceeding to peer review must receive assessments from at least two qualified reviewers. ITJ employs double-blind peer review. The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for the final publication decision, informed by scientific validity, reviewer reports, journal relevance, and applicable legal and ethical requirements.
Credible concerns about submitted or published work must be examined, including allegations raised after publication. Editors may seek explanations or supporting records and consult the publisher or relevant institutions. Appropriate outcomes may include clarification, correction, expression of concern, or retraction.
The Editor-in-Chief retains authority over the journal's editorial content and publication decisions. When necessary, the Editor-in-Chief may seek advice from other editors or reviewers while ensuring that conflicted individuals do not participate in the decision.
Peer reviewers contribute independent and informed assessments that support fair editorial decisions and help maintain the quality of research disseminated by ITJ. The journal expects reviewers to uphold confidentiality, professional objectivity, research integrity, and independence from competing interests.
Reviewers assess scientific originality, methodological appropriateness, relevance to tourism scholarship, evidentiary support, and interpretation of findings. Their reasoned reports inform editorial decisions and provide constructive guidance to authors.
Invited reviewers should accept assignments only when they have suitable expertise and can meet the requested review period. A reviewer who lacks the necessary competence or cannot review promptly should notify the editorial office and decline the invitation.
Submitted manuscripts are confidential. Reviewers must not share, discuss, distribute, or reuse unpublished texts, data, results, or ideas without editorial authorization and the relevant written permission. The obligation also applies when a reviewer declines the invitation.
Reviews must be impartial, evidence-based, clear, and professionally expressed. Criticism should address the research, not the author. Reviewers should explain methodological weaknesses, unsupported claims, and other scholarly concerns sufficiently for an informed editorial response.
Reviewers should identify important relevant work omitted from citations and alert editors to suspected plagiarism, substantial textual overlap, duplicate publication, or other serious irregularities. Concerns should be supported by the information available to the reviewer.
Reviewers must promptly disclose any competing interests arising from personal, collaborative, institutional, commercial, or other relationships with authors or their organizations. Where impartiality is compromised, the reviewer should decline or withdraw from the assignment.
ITJ uses a double-blind peer-review system and requires at least two substantive review reports before an editorial acceptance decision. Further information is available in the journal's official peer-review policy.
Authors are responsible for the originality, accuracy, transparency, and ethical conduct of the scholarship they submit to ITJ. These responsibilities extend from the preparation of the manuscript to responses during peer review and to the identification and correction of significant errors after publication.
Authors must provide an honest, sufficiently detailed account of research questions, methods, data, findings, interpretations, and limitations. Fabrication, falsification, and knowingly inaccurate or misleading statements are unacceptable. Review manuscripts must present an objective and comprehensive analysis of the relevant scholarship.
Authors may be requested to provide relevant underlying data for editorial evaluation. Where practicable, research data should remain accessible to appropriately qualified professionals for at least 10 years after publication, while respecting participant confidentiality, intellectual property, contractual restrictions, and applicable law.
Submitted work must be original, and the research and words of others must be properly attributed. Plagiarism, unattributed paraphrasing, misappropriation of results, and misleading presentation of others' contributions are prohibited. Authors must complete the journal's statement of originality when required.
A manuscript must not be submitted simultaneously to more than one journal or presented as a new original publication if it has already been substantially published. Any legitimate secondary publication requires prior agreement, transparency, and clear citation of the primary publication.
Authorship is reserved for individuals who made substantive research contributions, participated in drafting or critical revision, and approved the final manuscript. Contributors who do not meet authorship criteria should be acknowledged appropriately, with permission when their names are included.
Authors must disclose financial and non-financial interests that could affect the research or its interpretation, including affiliations, employment, consultancy, funding, and relevant relationships. All research funding and available grant identifiers should be accurately reported.
Authors must properly acknowledge significant intellectual sources. Information obtained privately through correspondence, professional discussions, confidential peer review, or other restricted activities must not be published or used without the required explicit written authorization.
Research involving people or animals must comply with relevant legal and institutional ethical standards, including approvals and informed consent where applicable. Researchers must protect participants' privacy and identify significant hazards associated with the procedures, materials, or equipment used.
Authors must cooperate with legitimate editorial requests for clarification, data, ethics approvals, consent documentation, and permissions. Revisions should address reviewers' comments systematically and be returned within the deadline set by the editorial team.
Authors who identify major errors or inaccuracies in their published articles must promptly inform the editorial office and cooperate with a suitable correction, clarification, or retraction. Authors are also expected to respond to credible concerns raised by other parties.
The corresponding author should verify that all qualified coauthors are included, that individuals who do not qualify are not listed as authors, and that every coauthor has approved the final manuscript and its submission to ITJ.
The publisher of ITJ, CV. Austronesia Akademika, Indonesia, supports responsible publication practice, transparent management of the scholarly record, and the long-term availability of published research. Academic publication decisions remain the responsibility of the authorized editorial team.
The publisher cooperates with the editorial team to prevent fraudulent publication, plagiarism, research misconduct, and other serious ethical violations. It must not encourage or knowingly permit unethical publication practices.
Where publication misconduct or major errors are alleged or established, the publisher supports proportionate investigation and editorial action. Possible responses include clarifications, published corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions when warranted.
The publisher supports continued access to and preservation of the scholarly record through the ITJ online journal platform, appropriate archiving arrangements, and sustainable management of publication metadata and published content.
Administrative and publishing support must not override impartial scientific evaluation. Research integrity, responsible correction of the scholarly record, and public accessibility are shared responsibilities of the publisher and editorial team.
ITJ recognizes that concerns about publication integrity can emerge before or after an article is published. Credible reports should receive a proportionate, fair, and evidence-informed editorial response. Where relevant, guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) may inform the handling of such cases.
Concerns about data integrity, plagiarism, authorship, duplicate publication, conflicts of interest, ethical approval, or errors may arise during submission, peer review, or after publication.
Editors examine the reported concern and relevant evidence, determine the nature and seriousness of the issue, and may request an explanation or supporting documentation from the parties involved.
Where justified, the journal may consult the publisher, independent experts, or relevant research institutions. The process should respect confidentiality, impartiality, and the opportunity for affected parties to respond.
Depending on the evidence and seriousness of the issue, the journal may issue a clarification, correction, expression of concern, or retraction, or take other proportionate action consistent with the publication record.
Post-publication notices should clearly identify the article concerned and explain the nature of the amendment or concern, while retaining a reliable and discoverable record of the journal's editorial response.
Used where a published article requires an identifiable amendment to repair an error without necessarily invalidating its principal findings.
May alert readers to a substantial unresolved integrity issue while appropriate examination is ongoing or necessary evidence remains inconclusive.
May be appropriate when sufficiently established errors or misconduct make the published findings unreliable or render the publication ethically unacceptable.
ITJ refers to relevant COPE guidance when considering suspected misconduct, editorial accountability, and corrections or retractions. Reference to COPE guidance does not, by itself, constitute a claim of formal COPE membership.
These responsibilities are shared by authors, reviewers, editors, and the publisher. A documented and fair editorial response should prioritize the reliability of the published evidence, accountability to readers, and responsible scholarly communication.
Indonesian Tourism Journal This work is licensed under
a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License![]()
Published by:
CV. Austronesia Akademika, Tanjungpinang City. Kepulauan Riau Province. Indonesia
Email: [email protected] | Website: austronesiaakademika.com